The k2p blog

If MH370 was in fact hijacked and this report from Reuters (in full below)  about the radar data is correct, then the “diverted” flight path of MH370 looked like this: (See expanded map here via The Guardian for details). Somebody with much experience of flying must have been in charge of the aircraft. No doubt the passengers and crew are being investigated to see who else apart from the pilots had that kind of experience.

MH370 Presumed Diverted Flight Path

(See also this map reconstructed and tweeted by Singapore Today and this one from AirInfo. All are based on the Reuters report and the locations of the navigation waypoints).

UPDATE! —  The presumed flight path – even if correct – is 7 days old. The Indian search effort is now to include hundreds of uninhabited islands in the Andaman and Nicobar chain. (Of 572 islands in the chain only 37 are inhabited).

The WSJ also seems to confirm the flight of the plane westwards.

Malaysia Airlines’ missing jet transmitted its location repeatedly to satellites over the course of five hours after it disappeared from radar, people briefed on the matter said, as searchers zeroed in on new target areas hundreds of miles west of the plane’s original course.

The satellites also received speed and altitude information about the plane from its intermittent “pings,” the people said. The final ping was sent from over water, at what one of these people called a normal cruising altitude. They added that it was unclear why the pings stopped. One of the people, an industry official, said it was possible that the system sending them had been disabled by someone on board.

The people, who included a military official, the industry official and others, declined to say what specific path the transmissions revealed. But the U.S. planned to move surveillance planes into an area of the Indian Ocean 1,000 miles or more west of the Malay peninsula where the plane took off, said Cmdr. William Marks, the spokesman for the U.S. Seventh Fleet.

(Reuters) –

Radar data suggests missing Malaysia plane deliberately flown way off course – sources

Military radar data suggests a Malaysia Airlines jetliner missing for nearly a week was deliberately flown hundreds of miles off course, heightening suspicions of foul play among investigators, sources told Reuters on Friday.

Analysis of the Malaysia data suggests the plane, with 239 people on board, diverted from its intended northeast route from Kuala Lumpur to Beijing and flew west instead, using airline flight corridors normally employed for routes to the Middle East and Europe, said sources familiar with investigations into the Boeing 777’s disappearance.

Two sources said an unidentified aircraft that investigators believe was Flight MH370 was following a route between navigational waypoints when it was last plotted on military radar off the country’s northwest coast.

This indicates that it was either being flown by the pilots or someone with knowledge of those waypoints, the sources said.

The last plot on the military radar’s tracking suggested the plane was flying toward India’s Andaman Islands, a chain of isles between the Andaman Sea and the Bay of Bengal, they said.

Waypoints are geographic locations, worked out by calculating longitude and latitude, that help pilots navigate along established air corridors.

A third source familiar with the investigation said inquiries were focusing increasingly on the theory that someone who knew how to fly a plane deliberately diverted the flight.

POSSIBLE SABOTAGE OR HIJACK

“What we can say is we are looking at sabotage, with hijack still on the cards,” said that source, a senior Malaysian police official.

All three sources declined to be identified because they were not authorized to speak to the media and due to the sensitivity of the investigation.

Officials at Malaysia’s Ministry of Transport, the official point of contact for information on the investigation, did not return calls seeking comment.

Malaysian police have previously said they were investigating whether any passengers or crew had personal or psychological problems that might shed light on the mystery, along with the possibility of a hijacking, sabotage or mechanical failure.

As a result of the new evidence, the sources said, multinational search efforts were being stepped up in the Andaman Sea and also the Indian Ocean.

LAST SIGHTING

In one of the most baffling mysteries in modern aviation, no trace of the plane nor any sign of wreckage has been found despite a search by the navies and military aircraft of more than a dozen countries.

The last sighting of the aircraft on civilian radar screens came shortly before 1:30 a.m. Malaysian time last Saturday (1730 GMT Friday), less than an hour after it took off from Kuala Lumpur, as the plane flew northeast across the mouth of the Gulf of Thailand. That put the plane on Malaysia’s east coast.

Malaysia’s air force chief said on Wednesday an aircraft that could have been the missing plane was plotted on military radar at 2:15 a.m., 200 miles northwest of Penang Island off Malaysia’s west coast.

This position marks the limit of Malaysia’s military radar in that part of the country, a fourth source familiar with the investigation told Reuters.

When asked about the range of military radar at a news conference on Thursday, Malaysian Transport Minister Hishammuddin Hussein said it was “a sensitive issue” that he was not going to reveal.

“Even if it doesn’t extend beyond that, we can get the co-operation of the neighboring countries,” he said.

The fact that the aircraft – if it was MH370 – had lost contact with air traffic control and was invisible to civilian radar suggested someone on board had turned off its communication systems, the first two sources said.

They also gave new details on the direction in which the unidentified aircraft was heading – following aviation corridors identified on maps used by pilots as N571 and P628. These routes are taken by commercial planes flying from Southeast Asia to the Middle East or Europe and can be found in public documents issued by regional aviation authorities.

In a far more detailed description of the military radar plotting than has been publicly revealed, the first two sources said the last confirmed position of MH370 was at 35,000 feet about 90 miles off the east coast of Malaysia, heading towards Vietnam, near a navigational waypoint called “Igari”. The time was 1:21 a.m..

The military track suggests it then turned sharply westwards, heading towards a waypoint called “Vampi”, northeast of Indonesia’s Aceh province and a navigational point used for planes following route N571 to the Middle East.

From there, the plot indicates the plane flew towards a waypoint called “Gival”, south of the Thai island of Phuket, and was last plotted heading northwest towards another waypoint called “Igrex”, on route P628 that would take it over the Andaman Islands and which carriers use to fly towards Europe.

The time was then 2:15 a.m. That is the same time given by the air force chief on Wednesday, who gave no information on that plane’s possible direction.

The sources said Malaysia was requesting raw radar data from neighbours Thailand, Indonesia and India, which has a naval base in the Andaman Islands.

We are into Day 7 after the aircraft’s disappearance and there is still very little confirmed. But it is getting very weird.

=========================

While US information is taking the search towards a hijacking and westwards, the Chinese have now reported a seismic event on the sea floor between Malaysia and Vietnam about 1.5 hours after the plane lost contact which suggests a catastrophic plunge into the sea along or close to the aircraft’s planned flight path.

Malaysian Insider: Chinese researchers have detected a “seafloor event” near the waters between Malaysia and Vietnam, an area suspected to be linked to the missing MH370 jetliner, reported Xinhua. The event occurred about one and a half hours after the plane’s last definitive sighting on civilian radar, a research group on seismology and physics from the University of Science and Technology of China was quoted as saying.

The research group told the Chinese news agency that the area – which is 116 km northeast from where the last contact with the Boeing plane was recorded – was a non-seismic region. “The seafloor event could have been caused by the plane possibly plunging into the sea,” said the group.

If the plane flew on for 4 or 5 hours after ceasing communication – then it must have been hijacked. When the pinging ceased the plane may not have crashed if the hijackers were sophisticated enough to shut it off as they had done with the transponders. The aircraft could then have continued flying after the pinging ceased. No black box signal suggests that it has not encountered water (or that it has been completely destroyed). If the black box has not been destroyed it must be on land. If on land the plane could could have crashed or it has been landed. If it has landed then the passengers may still be alive.

But I can make no sense of who such hijackers could be and where they could have been headed to.

=========================

US officials believe the flight’s two communication systems were “systematically shut down”, indicating that the plane’s disappearence may not have been due to a catastrophic failure, according to ABC News. “The data reporting system, they believe, was shut down at 1.07am. The transponder – which transmits location and altitude – shut down at 1.21am,” the report says.

Hereandnow: Wall Street Journal reporter Andy Pasztor made news today with his story that missing Malaysian Airlines flight 370 could have flown for four more hours after its last confirmed contact, based on information routinely relayed from its Rolls Royce engines.

Malaysian officials denied that today. But Pasztor also claims that American investigators are debating whether “something weird and bizarre” and still unexplained happened in the cockpit, and that the Boeing 777 did not crash when it dropped off the radar, but may have landed.

=========================

Foul play seems to be back into the picture with air piracy followed by a descent into water now assumed for the new search area.

National Post: 

Aviation specialists investigating last week’s loss of Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 say evidence gathered so far suggests the plane veered off its path toward Beijing and travelled west over Malaysia toward the Andaman Sea, beyond the detection limits of the country’s radars, according to the people, who asked not to be identified because the probe is active.

ABC News, citing a senior Pentagon official, said the plane may have crashed into the Indian Ocean. With no evidence of a mechanical failure or pilot error, U.S. investigators are treating the disappearance as a case of air piracy, though it remains unclear by whom, one person said.

India’s search team has been asked to explore “very specific coordinates in the Andaman Sea,” said Syed Akbaruddin, a spokesman for the Indian foreign ministry, without elaborating on those coordinates.

=========================

Unconfirmed report that the engines continued to “ping” that they were ready to transmit infirmation and these pings were picked up by US communication satellites. Data was not transmitted because Malaysian Airlines does not subscribe to the service but the “pings” themselves are providing the indications that the plane continued flying and that it was westwards.

(now also reported here at ABC News: Malaysia Airliner Kept ‘Pinging’

========================

Malaysian Ministers continue to make silly statements:

This time the Communications Minister, Ahmad Shabery Cheek, is calling for nationalism and the cessation of all criticism of the government.

NST: “The government and those involved in the operation needs the people to support us. This is the time to unite under the banner of nationalism.”

==========================

What the new indications are are not known but the US thinks the aircraft may have come down even further west than previously ever envisaged. They believe the plane flew west for 4 or 5 hours after disappearing from the radar before crashing into the water. I would guess that the new indications are from satellite imagery. But a location so far west also suggests that the plane was diverted/hijacked and was being flown with all communication deliberately switched off.

At today’s press conference why did Malaysia dismiss the US report that the plane had flown on for 4 or 5 hours as being “inaccurate”?

Where? Myanmar? Thailand? India?

Could it actually have been landed somewhere? Seems unlikely.

Reuters: “It’s my understanding that based on some new information that’s not necessarily conclusive – but new information – an additional search area may be opened in the Indian Ocean,” White House spokesman Jay Carney said. “And we are consulting with international partners about the appropriate assets to deploy.

“The Star:U.S. officials have an “indication” the missing Malaysia Airlines plane may have crashed in the Indian Ocean and is moving the USS Kidd to the area to begin searching, according to ABC News. It quoted a senior Pentagon official as saying that it will take another 24 hours to move the ship into position. 
“We have an indication the plane went down in the Indian Ocean,” the senior official said.

===================

Eagle Radio:

Communications satellites picked up a faint ‘electronic ping’ from the missing Malaysian aircraft after contact was lost according to a source close to the investigation.

The signal was an indication the aircraft’s troubleshooting systems were ready to communicate with satellites if required, but no data was sent because Malaysia Airlines had not subscribed to the full troubleshooting service, the source said.

======================

===============================

The muddle continues.

The New York Times questions why the military did not react:

Military radar then detected an unidentified aircraft at several points, apparently headed west across the Malaysian peninsula and out into the Indian Ocean, the head of the country’s air force told reporters. The last detected location was hundreds of miles to the west of where search and rescue efforts were initially focused. The military took no immediate action on Saturday to investigate the unidentified blips, whose path appeared to take the aircraft near the heavily populated island of Penang, and only later realized the significance of the radar readings.

Or did they react in some crazy knee-jerk fashion …?

There is something not quite right about the military story. It could just be incompetence or it could be something else.

==============================

Malaysia’s defence and acting transport minister Hishammuddin Hussein (a cousin of the Prime Minister) just stated at the press conference that crew members homes were not “raided”. Now the Home Minister (Ahmad Zahid Hamidi) has announced that police did indeed visit their homes and families of crew members have indeed been questioned in a “search for clues”!!!!

The lack of command and control structure is apparent.

Reuters carries an analysis of the systemic ills in Malaysia.

The ruling United Malays National Organisation has long been criticized, including by some of its own members, for cronyism, an authoritarian streak and breeding a political culture in which loyalty is prized over talent. Majority ethnic Malays have benefited from a system of economic and social privileges that has steadily alienated ethnic Chinese and Indians, who make up large minorities in the nation of 29 million people.

…. Malaysia’s response has been overseen personally by Prime Minister Najib Razak, who put his cousin – the defense and acting transport minister Hishamuddin Hussein – in charge of day-to-day operations and interaction with the media. …… 

It goes on to warn that China may well fill the vacuum left by the lackadaisical approach to maritime awareness:

Bowers, the Southeast Asia specialist, said Malaysia’s apparent mishandling of the situation could have long-term strategic consequences in a region where China’s economic and military might is growing rapidly. “They have no maritime domain awareness and it doesn’t look like they have a strong command and control structure and they’re not well coordinated with friends. Sadly, that’s what the MH370 situation demonstrates,” he said of Malaysia.

=================================

A new press conference is under way:

• Day 6, 12 countries searching, 40+ships, 40+aircraft >>> nothing new
• search continues – both eastwards and westwards
• Rolls Royce and Boeing received no information from the plane after 1.07am on Saturday morning.
• police had not raided the homes of crew members (but it is implied that some kind of investigation is ongoing)
• the Chinese satellite images were “released by mistake” and without authorisation says Chinese Ambassador statement
• The report of 4 hours of continued flying is “inaccurate” — is just the reported time duration inaccurate?

======================

Was the plane shot down by mistake? If the military picked up the plane on radar how was it determined to be “friendly”? Seems incredible but it is day 6 and ……….

CCTV Twitter stream

CCTV 1

CCTV 2

=============================

The WSJ says that data automatically downloaded for maintenance from the B777 engines suggest that the plane was in the air for 4 hours

Flight 370 stayed in the air for about four hours past the time it reached its last confirmed location, according to two people familiar with the details, raising the possibility that the plane could have flown on for hundreds of additional miles under conditions that remain murky.

Four hours could have taken the plane to India or to the North-Western coast of Australia.

====================

They are not compelling but the proximity of the suspected crash site from the Chinese satellite images to the location reported by an oil rig worker who saw a burning aircraft adds some credibility to the theory that the plane went down along its projected flight path. Probably soon after the last reported contact. But why there is so little surface wreckage remains unanswered.

The above image shows the approximate coordinates given by a New Zealand oil rig worker who believes he may have seen flight MH370 crash. The lower image plots the coordinates given by Chinese authorities of the large pieces of debris spotted by satellite on Sunday March 9. Photograph: /Map data : AutoNavi, Google, Kingway, MapIT, ZENRIN (via The Guardian)

The Chinese satellite images are from Sunday but there is no wreckage at the location now.

=======================

Further examples of the “incompetence” of the Malaysian authorities comes from this Washington Post article showing doctored pictures of the two Iranians who travelled on false passports. It is said to be a photocopying error and nothing malicious by the Malaysian police. maybe not malicious  but pretty incompetent.

======================

UPDATE: 2200 CET 12th March — CNN reports from a Chinese agency: “A Chinese satellite looking into the missing Flight 370 “observed a suspected crash area at sea.” CNN says that some pieces which could have been large pieces of wreckage were observed in satellite images from Sunday. The suspected crash site is in the vicinity of the last known position of the aircraft.

Images were published by the Chinese State Administration for Science, Technology and Industry for National Defense (SASTIND), and dated March 9. They show a suspected crash site in the South China Sea, not far off the plane’s projected flight path. They show three large pieces at sea, the largest of which, according to SASTIND, measured 24m by 27m.

=====================

What on earth is going on?

UPDATE! It is still a few hours to first light in Malaysia and it is now over 5 days. 

Now they are calling in the witchdoctors! And an idiot shaman – who happens to be a muslim – is allowed by the international airport authorities to make a play for the headlines. As if Malaysia is not facing enough ridicule. What were they thinking?

The mystery surrounding the missing Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 has captured the attention of a well-known ‘bomoh’ (shaman), Ibrahim Mat Zin. Ibrahim, who is known as Raja Bomoh Sedunia Nujum VIP, arrived at the KL International Airport (KLIA) today, claiming to be invited by one of the country’s top leaders, to help locate the missing plane using a spiritual method and prayer. “We use fish trap hook and a bamboo binocular to look and ask for the victims to be found as soon as possible,” he told reporters here today. He was also seen to have performed a prayer at the KLIA entrance. “During my prayer, my eyes hurt and my vision turned black. I think the plane is still in the air or has crashed into the sea. I will come back here (to KLIA) in another two days after performing my prayers and I will bring something,” he said.

============================

Just when I thought that the Malaysian authorities would begin to get their act together, they seem to be going from bad to worse. Fishermen retrieved it and kept it safe until the Malaysian Maritime Enforcement Agency managed to sink what may have been a life raft from the ill-fated plane.

Today’s long delayed press conference is just over. Nothing new. It has been over 100 hours.

We are not confused. We know that we don’t know. It may have turned back or it may not have. It could be to the East or it could be to the West or it could be to the North West. We have to check if we knew about Boeing’s warnings about the B777. We can’t tell you why we are looking where we are. We don’t know what we don’t know. We are baffled there was no distress call.

The tragedy is now containing elements of farce from the Malaysian authorities.

MalayMail: 

KUALA LUMPUR, March 12 — A brief flash of hope when fisherman discovered what they thought was a raft from missing Malaysia Airlines (MAS) flight MH370 turned to despair when maritime authorities sank the craft in their attempt to recover it. 

According to the New Straits Times today, the yellow-and-black life raft emblazoned with the word “BOARDING” was spotted by a group of fishermen near Port Dickson in Negri Sembilan yesterday, who then alerted authorities.

“We managed to tie it to our boat as we feared it would sink due to the damage,” Azman Mohamad, one of the finders, told the newspaper.

Their fears proved real when the team dispatched from the Kuala Linggi Malaysian Maritime Enforcement Agency (MMEA) to retrieve the craft promptly sent it under the waves.

The report did not specify if the raft was now permanently lost.

The epidemic of official contradictions is now extending to the Chinese authorities:

Economic Times: China’s foreign ministry said on Wednesday that its aircraft are not conducting searches over land for a missing Malaysia Airlines jetliner but that it was expanding searches at sea. Ministry spokesman Qin Gang made the statement at a regular press briefing. Earlier in the day the chief of China’s civil aviation authority said that searches would be broadened to include land areas. 

UPDATE:

AFP: “Total Incompetence”

“It’s bad enough for a wide-body jet to go missing with 239 people on board, but then for the responsible country’s government and aviation agencies to handle the associated information with total incompetence is unforgivable,” said David Learmount from industry magazine Flightglobal.

There is more than a hint of incompetence in the air. Now the search area is being extended to the Andaman Sea and the vicinity of Japan! Japan and India have confirmed they are to join the search at the request of Malaysia.

=========================

It is now Day 5 since the disappearance of MH370 and Malaysian authorities are not giving the impression that they know what they are doing. The plane that was “found” has been “unfound”. The Chief of the Air Force has “unsaid” what he is reported to have said yesterday. He now denies that he said that the plane had been tracked to the Straits of Malacca.

(Reuters) – Malaysia’s air force chief denied a media report that the military last tracked a missing Malaysia Airlines jetliner over the Strait of Malacca, far from where it last made contact with civilian air traffic control when it disappeared four days ago.

“I wish to state that I did not make any such statements,” air force chief Rodzali Daud said in a statement on Wednesday.

Now searches are including land masses for the first time.

(Reuters) – China’s air force will add two planes to the search for a missing Malaysia Airlines jetliner, the country’s civil aviation chief said on Wednesday, adding that search and rescue efforts would be broadened to include land areas.

High ranking Malaysian officials are distinguishing themselves by contradicting their earlier statements. The statement by the Chief of the Air Force is just the latest in a series of mis-statements.

Malaysian blog comments are scathing in their criticism of the incompetence of their authorities. Just a couple of examples from Malaysiakini:

these donkeys don’t even know whether the plane flew east or west from KLIA! The whole world is laughing at us.

Real stupid….DCA says five bagages were removed from plane and now Some idiot says four never check in…..?? Whose bagage that they checked then ?? 

It all started with the Home Minister who felt it necessary to protect himself by blaming immigration officials. There are suggestions of incompetence as Vietnam calls off part of its search because of lack of response and clarity from Malaysia.

The Guardian:

… this update on how the search progressed today:

The search for the missing Malaysia Airlines flight was descending into confusion and acrimony on Wednesday as Vietnam called off part of its search pending further information from Malaysia.

As families spent a fifth day waiting for news of flight MH370, which vanished with 239 people on board, disagreements within the international search operation were surfacing and Malaysian officials failed to clarify the aircraft’s last known movement

Vietnam has also halted part of their search efforts:

Vietnam said it had halted its air search and scaled back a sea search while it waited for Malaysia to offer more detail.

…. One of the issues that stands out is the contradictions made by different Malaysian authorities involved in the investigation. As they write:

Only two are known to have been travelling on stolen passports. Both are thought to be Iranian, probably seeking asylum in Europe, Interpol’s secretary general has said.

There was confusion earlier because the Malaysian home minister had described them as appearing to be Asian but was then contradicted by the civil aviation chief, who appeared to suggest that one of the men looked like the black Italian footballer Mario Balotelli. Most journalists present took that to mean that he was black, although the Ministry of Transportation later clarified that the civil aviation chief, Azharuddin Abdul Rahman, had been trying to emphasise that ethnicity did not indicate nationality.

And again:

On Monday, the civil aviation chief said five people checked in but did not board and their baggage was removed accordingly. On Tuesday, the inspector general of police said that everyone who was booked on to the flight had boarded – though he then contradicted himself by saying one person had missed the flight because they got the wrong day. Malaysia Airlines says that four people were booked but never checked in.

And once more (although this change is from Malaysia Airlines):

This is perhaps the most confusing aspect of all. Malaysia Airlines repeatedly said that Subang air traffic control – which covers Kuala Lumpur airport – lost contact with the aircraft at 2.40am, almost two hours after takeoff, but later revised its last known contact to 1.30am.

……  There’s been significant criticism of the handling of the search, particularly of the comments made by Malaysian police chief Khalid Abu Bakar. The official said on Tuesday that there were four scenarios they were likely looking at: “We are looking into four areas: one hijacking, two sabotage, three psychological problems of the passengers and crew and four personal problems among the passengers and crew.” Here’s how these comments have been received:

Steve Marks, a lawyer at the US firm Podhurst Orseck, which represented relatives of victims of a SilkAir crash in Asia in 1997 and the Air France crash in 2009, said he was suspicious of information being released by Malaysia.

On Tuesday Malaysian investigators said they were still looking at a range of theories including hijacking and possible sabotage by a passenger or crew member.

Marks said: “In my opinion terrorism and pilot suicide are very remote and farfetched. It can’t be ruled out 100% but it certainly shouldn’t be the focus. That kind of speculation without proof is very damaging and hurtful to the families.”

Marks said the complete lack of any information about what happened to the plane does tended to support the view of “a complete catastrophic failure at altitude.”

Malaysian officials have started blaming the media and are complaining about their “bullying”!

UPDATE!

Now it gets eerie! 

ZEE NEWS: “the cellphones of the passengers on the missing plane were ringing, but went unanswered …..  concerned families of the missing passengers managed to connect the calls successfully, but no one picked the call.” If this is correct and the plane is in water then it cannot be very deep down.

=========================

According to a report on the Swedish radio web-site the aircraft has been “found” (tracked) by military radar in the Malacca Straits. It is not yet completely certain that this is MH370 but the searches to the east of Malaysia have been called off.

The Malacca Straits would fit with the aircraft trying to get back to Kuala Lumpur. But the lack of communication remains a mystery.

According to Dagens Nyheter it could have come down in an area which was a “radar blind spot”. That doesn’t explain the journey to the “blind spot” of course.

Pulau Perak

Reuters:

Malaysian authorities have previously said flight MH370 disappeared about an hour after it took off from Kuala Lumpur for the Chinese capital Beijing.

At the time it was roughly midway between Malaysia’s east coast town of Kota Bharu and the southern tip of Vietnam, flying at 35,000 ft (10,670 metres).

“It changed course after Kota Bharu and took a lower altitude. It made it into the Malacca Strait,” the military official, who has been briefed on investigations, told Reuters.  …. Earlier on Tuesday, Malaysia’s Berita Harian newspaper quoted air force chief Rodzali Daud as saying the Malaysia Airlines plane was last detected by military radar at 2:40 a.m. on Saturday, near the island of Pulau Perak at the northern end of the Strait of Malacca. It was flying at a height of about 9,000 metres (29,500 ft), he was quoted as saying. ….. If the reports from the military are verified, it would mean the plane was able to maintain a cruising altitude and flew for about 500 km (350 miles) with its transponder and other tracking systems apparently switched off.